← Return to topic

What popular game did you play and say "ok yeah I get it."

JellyBaV · 6 Sep 2026 at 17:05 · permalink

Feel like across reddit I see people ask "what popular game did you not really like" a lot. Wanted to go the other direction and see what games you guys played and understood the hype.

For me it was Zelda Breath of the Wild and RDR2.

Egor93 · 6 Sep 2026 at 17:10 · permalink

Expedition 33. Typically not big on turn based but that game absolutely blew me away. Spent 100+ hours on one playthrough just to explore everything the world had to offer.

DevochkaSkandaL · 6 Sep 2026 at 17:11 · permalink

I was not expecting to enjoy Expedition 33. I was at a stage in life freshly sober and determined to expand my horizons, and it put me in a place where I realized I need to "stop and smell the roses" more in games, and in life.

meoland · 6 Sep 2026 at 17:11 · permalink

Titanfall 2

meoland · 6 Sep 2026 at 17:11 · permalink

Hollow Knight, and by extension, Silksong

REDFLANKER · 6 Sep 2026 at 17:11 · permalink

Death Stranding. After years of dismissing it as a walking sim I finally tried it and yes, it is but also no. The vibe of that game is so unique. Also absolutely hooked on Low Roar now.

REDFLANKER · 6 Sep 2026 at 17:14 · permalink

Says a lot the game still has such a healthy player base. Hopefully Respawn makes TF3 someday

faidd · 6 Sep 2026 at 17:15 · permalink

Elden Ring.

My guest attempt at a Souls game was Bloodborne as part of the PS+ PS5 selection of free games. I'd heard so much about how great the game was, attempting playing Bloodborne for about 30 minutes and then gave up.

Then, a little later I decided to try Demon's Souls Remake. I played it for about 25 hours, but ultimately gave up. I did enjoy it a bit more than my attempt at Bloodborne, but I didn't yet understand how to really play these games, so it wasn't an experience that I really liked all that much.

Then the hype surrounding Elden Ring got me. What people were saying about the open world got me to give the genre another chance. I was determined to get these games. And after about 20 hours with Elden Ring, it just clicked. I figured out what made them fun for me, and I haven't looked back. I love the genre (playing Mortal Shell 2 right now).

yoyoyoyo999 · 6 Sep 2026 at 17:18 · permalink

I'd echo Breath Of the Wild. I took about a decade off of gaming and bought a used switch last year with a bunch of games. Breath of the Wild was the first game to really grab me and make me want to keep playing in exploring since I became a working adult. Holds up great since my standards for graphics are from the 360 era.

s1nce_2k · 6 Sep 2026 at 17:18 · permalink

And by extension….. Price of Persia tlc, ori(s), nine sols, even Celeste.

Did not think I would like HK, took me a few tries then I couldn’t put it down. Idk what happened meteoidvanias took over my life for like a year it was amazing. Glad a found a new genre I enjoy.

faidd · 6 Sep 2026 at 17:19 · permalink

Hollow knight, the original

jason_zhuang · 6 Sep 2026 at 17:21 · permalink

Mass Effect. I hopped on that train only by the time Andromeda came out, so going through the full trilogy genuinely blew my tits clean off. I now sport like 18 playthroughs. Fav games ever.

FLOUDY · 6 Sep 2026 at 17:22 · permalink

Slay The Spire. I didn’t get the appeal of card-based videogames at all. Well, now I do. It’s actually a great format for turn-based games, especially when as well-balanced yet with as much build variety as STS.