We spend more time deciding what to play than actually playing. Everybody says anything is fine, then suddenly has an opinion once a game launches. Anyone solved this without a spreadsheet?

Rotate who picks. The only agreement is that everyone owns the game and we give it one short session before changing.

We keep a list of three games. If the list gets longer, picking becomes the evening again. Also decide before people join voice.

Three choices and a rotating picker sounds good. I suspect anything is fine really means please make the decision for me.