What game should’ve been right up your alley on paper, but just never hooked you?

You know the kind of game I mean. You look at everything it offers—the genre, setting, combat, story, developer, whatever—and think, “This is literally made for me.”

Then you actually play it…and nothing.

Maybe you even recognize that it’s a good game. You can understand why other people love it. But for whatever reason, you keep putting it down or have to force yourself to continue.

What game was that for you, and what do you think stopped it from clicking?

Bonus points if (1) it’s a game you’ve tried to get into more than once because you really wanted to like it, (2) it became the genre’s go-to standard/fan-favorite, (3) you’ve played basically every other game in that genre and (4) it’s currently staring at you from your library lol.