Random Number GodsRNG · Enemy Territory · Battlefield · D&D
Friday BF64 + Sunday D&D

Check the calendar. ET pubs running the new Frostbite rotation all week.

Does 2024 rules true strike work with a 2 handed weapon or a shield/sword combo?

Permalink Preview Print D&D
3264gggg
Covert Ops
Members
54 posts 15 Dec 2021 joined
6 Sep 2026 at 15:52 #1

I’ve been trying to figure it out but I just get more confused. Can anyone help me understand?

3264gggg - Server regular
If et-1 is up, I am up.

dLujo4k
Engineer
Members
45 posts 17 May 2024 joined
6 Sep 2026 at 15:53 #2

Yes, why wouldn't it?

dLujo4k - Axis defense
Do not walk my MG line twice.

3264gggg
Covert Ops
Members
54 posts 15 Dec 2021 joined
6 Sep 2026 at 15:55 #3

I was under the impression that if both hands were full, you wouldn’t have a free hand for the somatic aspect of the spell

3264gggg - Server regular
If et-1 is up, I am up.

powerp00
Engineer
Members
38 posts 17 Jan 2020 joined
6 Sep 2026 at 15:55 #4

When you cast a spell with a Material component, the hand holding it can also be used for the Somatic component.

powerp00 - D&D nights
Nat 1s are character development.

CorndogCrusader
Covert Ops
Members
59 posts 3 Mar 2024 joined
6 Sep 2026 at 15:56 #5

It works because you can use the same hand for the material component (which is your weapon) to also do the somatic component

CorndogCrusader - Allies rifle
Spawn on me.

TRX123
Engineer
Members
39 posts 25 Jul 2019 joined
6 Sep 2026 at 15:58 #6

Since it has both somatic and material components you can do both with the weapon bearing hand.

Shield spell is the difficult one without War Caster.

TRX123 - Axis defense
Do not walk my MG line twice.

3264gggg
Covert Ops
Members
54 posts 15 Dec 2021 joined
6 Sep 2026 at 16:03 #7

So follow up question, the war caster feat says “Somatic Components. You can perform the Somatic components of spells even when you have weapons or a Shield in one or both hands.” Is that ONLY for spells that don’t have a material component, but DO have a somatic component?

3264gggg - Server regular
If et-1 is up, I am up.

powerp00
Engineer
Members
38 posts 17 Jan 2020 joined
6 Sep 2026 at 16:03 #8

Yes, it would be redundant for any spell with a Material component.

powerp00 - D&D nights
Nat 1s are character development.

jfmarck
Engineer
Members
36 posts 12 Apr 2025 joined
6 Sep 2026 at 16:09 #9

I would say it would work with free action-drop weapon, but RAW you can't use a free action outside of your turn. Some DMs may grant you that but it's homebrew territory at this point. Dropping a weapon ON your turn in anticipation of potentially needing Shield can work, but an enemy can pick it up, kick it... I guess a mace on a wrist leather strap might work tho. You just won't be entitled to opportunity attacks unless you just punch/kick, but if you were weapon-dropping for Shield it's unlikely you'll switch to opportunity attack at the last second.

jfmarck - Trial / new blood
Still learning the smokes.

Vivat_Hussaria
Covert Ops
Members
52 posts 29 May 2020 joined
6 Sep 2026 at 16:10 #10

Side note, you only need two hands to actually make an attack with a two-handed weapon. You can hold it with just one hand, e.g. while casting a spell.

Vivat_Hussaria - BF support
Ammo box is friendship.

TopGood
Engineer
Members
36 posts 28 Feb 2020 joined
6 Sep 2026 at 16:16 #11

🤦🏾‍♂️

OMG

TopGood - Comp flex
Put me where you need a body.

hugomora
Panzer Ace
Members
121 posts 3 Sep 2025 joined
6 Sep 2026 at 16:20 #12

Not just any material component, specifically material components that are your weapon or shield

hugomora - Server regular
If et-1 is up, I am up.

3264gggg
Covert Ops
Members
54 posts 15 Dec 2021 joined
6 Sep 2026 at 16:27 #13

Cry about it I guess

3264gggg - Server regular
If et-1 is up, I am up.

Sign in to reply.