Overall, I prefer the New Order. For just mindless fun and relaxation New Colossus is probably better. The only area where I think NC consistently beats NO is in visual effects and lighting.

TNO by far. It is less silly and overt. Does Not jump the shark. Combat feel and Encounter Design manages to be better even though it is technologically far inferior

TNC because it's not afraid to be insane. The story is the most entertaining in the series and the gunplay is just as good as its ever been, plus it looks sooo much more colorful and vibrant.

Tnc

Yup same for me

While I do like New Order's OST more, I think New Colossus takes the cake for me for the gunplay alone. I also think that its less grim theme makes sense from a story perspective

New Order, but both are great

Bang on. TBO has the horrors of war. Colossus has a fun big gun

Exactly this

mysterious downvotes

Yes

TNO: better narrative, better boss battles, interesting villain

TNC: narrative and characters get seriously cringy, last battle is just insulting, but you can dual-wield anything

i prefer neither id rather play old blood

New order and it’s not even close

I’d probably pick New Order overall, though The New Colossus has some unforgettable set pieces. New Order feels more consistent, while NC swings between incredible highs and moments that feel a bit over-the-top.