Random Number GodsRNG · Enemy Territory · Battlefield · D&D
Friday BF64 + Sunday D&D

Check the calendar. ET pubs running the new Frostbite rotation all week.

This ruleset has to exist right?

Permalink Preview Print D&D
al3x067
Field Medic
Members
33 posts 23 Sep 2022 joined
10 Sep 2026 at 13:11 #1

Howdy all.

So I'm making a game with a stat system directly connected to how many dice you roll, and I want to ask if anyone else has knowledge of similar systems?

Basically, you have a Stat, and then a Skill. Say, Deduction\[Brains\], or Skill\[Stat\].

You have a Deduction of 3, and a Brains of 5, Ergo, you roll 5 Dice, with +3 to score.

Is there any other games like this that come to mind?

al3x067 - Lurker
I read more than I post.

ziguadongnange
Engineer
Members
36 posts 29 Jan 2021 joined
10 Sep 2026 at 13:11 #2

r/RPGdesign should be the best place for those kind of questions.

ziguadongnange - Server regular
If et-1 is up, I am up.

burningrubber
Engineer
Members
42 posts 18 Nov 2021 joined
10 Sep 2026 at 13:11 #3

Yeah, I think Silhouette (Heavy Gear, Jovian Chronicles) works like that

burningrubber - ET pubs
See you on rng-et-1.

hugomora
Panzer Ace
Members
121 posts 3 Sep 2025 joined
10 Sep 2026 at 13:11 #4

World of Darkness and L5R have similar concepts, though in both of those, you roll together two sets of dice. I know one of the L5R editions had a specialty you could take. That gave you a static bonus. So for example, if you have Agility of 3 and a weapon skill at 6, then you would roll 9 dice. If you have the appropriate specialization, then after you determine your final total, you add 6 to it.

I do not recall any system with a dice pool plus static as a whole. Does seem like something exists; I just don't know it.

hugomora - Server regular
If et-1 is up, I am up.

fasroi
Engineer
Members
47 posts 31 Aug 2019 joined
10 Sep 2026 at 13:11 #5

Roll for Shoes! You only have Skills though and it's ultra light.

fasroi - Lurker
I read more than I post.

toninhopl
Engineer
Members
48 posts 28 Oct 2021 joined
10 Sep 2026 at 13:11 #6

Its not quite the same, but the Song of Ice and Fire rpg has you roll a number of dice equal to your skill, and then you keep a number of dice from that roll equal to your attribute.

toninhopl - EU evenings
CET after work.

drkappaa
Field Medic
Members
32 posts 15 Nov 2022 joined
10 Sep 2026 at 13:11 #7

It has to exist just can't find it so your probably good. If you get sued by some underground ttrpg we will help you fight them :) (if im free)

drkappaa - Trial / new blood
Still learning the smokes.

qIlostp
Field Medic
Members
32 posts 8 Dec 2018 joined
10 Sep 2026 at 13:11 #8

Shadowrun has had two systems over the years:

1) Early one had you roll as many d6 as your skill rating was, while relevant stats added up to an X Pool (Combat Pool, Matrix Pool, Magic Pool, that sort of thing). You could add dice from a relevant pool to your rolls, but they would only be refreshed next round.

2) Later they switched to a straightforward system where you just roll a number of d6s equal to your attribute+skill ratings, with mostly fixed attribute to skill linkage, and numerous modifiers also expressed through adding or removing d6s from that roll.

qIlostp - Trial / new blood
Still learning the smokes.

al3x067
Field Medic
Members
33 posts 23 Sep 2022 joined
10 Sep 2026 at 13:11 #9

Thank you, I didn't know that subreddit existed.

al3x067 - Lurker
I read more than I post.

Artemka1950
Covert Ops
Members
60 posts 13 Oct 2019 joined
10 Sep 2026 at 13:11 #10

This sounds a lot like the Cortex system. Stats and skills are both dice, and you level dice up to bigger dice when you spend xp.

Artemka1950 - Axis defense
Do not walk my MG line twice.

fuerza31
Engineer
Members
40 posts 25 Apr 2026 joined
10 Sep 2026 at 13:11 #11

The One Ring rpg does something like this, except that:
- it’s the other way round, so the number of dice you roll depends on the ranks you have in the skill, rather than on the attribute;
- the +X modifier is replaced by a reduced target number. Target numbers are fixed as 20 less attribute score. If your example, the target number for Deduction would be fixed at 17.

fuerza31 - BF support
Ammo box is friendship.

xKittyhawk
Squad Lead
Members
87 posts 24 Sep 2025 joined
10 Sep 2026 at 13:11 #12

You are describing the very first dice pool system, invented for West End Games' Ghostbusters from 1986.

xKittyhawk - D&D nights
Nat 1s are character development.

ken7705
Covert Ops
Members
52 posts 11 Feb 2024 joined
10 Sep 2026 at 13:11 #13

Tabletop game mechanics can't be copyrighted (only the way they are written) so they can't be sued even if someone else came up with it first.

ken7705 - BF64s
PTFO or mute.

kilfin
Field Medic
Members
34 posts 29 Jul 2021 joined
10 Sep 2026 at 13:11 #14

WEG Star Wars.
Attribute + Skill = Total D6 rolled BUT each one is in itself represented by a d6 roll.

Strength : 4D6
Melee : 2D6

So for a Strength \[Melee\] check, you'd roll the sum of Strength and Melee = 6D6

Open D6 works this way, too.
https://ogc.rpglibrary.org/index.php?title=OpenD6

kilfin - D&D nights
Nat 1s are character development.

Minijudeu
Field Medic
Members
31 posts 22 Mar 2025 joined
10 Sep 2026 at 13:11 #15

I mean, all of World of Darkness uses that dice pool.

Minijudeu - BF support
Ammo box is friendship.

Sign in to reply.